13 July 2009

Did Galileo beat Le Verrier to the discovery of Neptune?

Science Daily reports that a Melbourne physicist has put forward a theory that Galileo knew he had discovered a new planet in 1613, 234 years before its official discovery date.
Professor David Jamieson, Head of the School of Physics, is investigating the Galileo’s notebooks and believes that he discovered a new planet that we now know as Neptune.

Galileo was observing the moons of Jupiter in the years 1612 and 1613 and recorded his observations in his notebooks. Over several nights he also recorded the position of a nearby star which does not appear in any modern star catalogue.

"It has been known for several decades that this unknown star was actually the planet Neptune. Computer simulations show the precision of his observations revealing that Neptune would have looked just like a faint star almost exactly where Galileo observed it," Professor Jamieson says.
But a planet is different to a star because planets orbit the Sun and move through the sky relative to the stars. It is remarkable that on the night of January 28 in 1613 Galileo noted that the "star" we now know is the planet Neptune appeared to have moved relative to an actual nearby star."

There is also a mysterious unlabeled black dot in his earlier observations of January 6, 1613, which is in the right position to be Neptune. "I believe this dot could reveal he went back in his notes to record where he saw Neptune earlier when it was even closer to Jupiter but had not previously attracted his attention because of its unremarkable star-like appearance."

If the mysterious black dot on January 6 was actually recorded on January 28, Professor Jamieson proposes this would prove that Galileo believed he may have discovered a new planet.

"Galileo may indeed have formed the hypothesis that he had seen a new planet which had moved right across the field of view during his observations of Jupiter over the month of January 1613," Professor Jamieson says."If this is correct Galileo observed Neptune 234 years before its official discovery."

But there could be an even more interesting possibility still buried in Galileo's notes and letters."Galileo was in the habit of sending a scrambled sentence, an anagram, to his colleagues to establish his priority for the sensational discoveries he made with his new telescope. He did this when he discovered the phases of Venus and the rings of Saturn. So perhaps somewhere he wrote an as-yet undecoded anagram that reveals he knew he discovered a new planet," Professor Jamieson speculates.

Well there you have it.

Source: University of Melbourne (2009, July 9). Galileo's Notebooks May Reveal Secrets Of New Planet. ScienceDaily. Retrieved July 12, 2009, from http://www.sciencedaily.com¬ /releases/2009/07/090709095427.htm


James Higham said...

Galileo-le Verrier, Neville- Shakespeare.

jams o donnell said...

Pah James Every one knows that Shakespeare's plays were written by a time travelling English scholar!

Steve Bates said...

"So perhaps somewhere he wrote an as-yet undecoded anagram that reveals he knew he discovered a new planet," Professor Jamieson speculates."

Oh, good grief...

* Galileo wrote anagrams to establish priority for his discoveries,

* We have found no such anagram for his possible discovery of Neptune, therefore...

* Galileo discovered Neptune first!

Jamieson made a pretty good case up to that point. He should have left well enough alone!

jams o donnell said...

Ah Good point Steve!